Iron Butterfly is one trade that a lot of traders in India try. So this article may be help to a lot of traders.
When To Trade Iron Butterfly:
This trade can be done when there is a sudden rise in volatility and the trader expects the volatility to drop in a few days and the stock to be range bound. Both volatility drop and passage of time helps the iron butterfly trade.
How To Trade Iron Butterfly:
Four trades are involved:
1) Sell One ATM (at the money) Call Option,
2) Sell One ATM (at the money) Put Option,
3) Buy One OTM (out of the money) Call Option, &
4) Buy One OTM (out of the money) Put Option.
The OTM call option is bought to protect the unlimited loss in the sold call option. And the OTM put option is bought to protect the unlimited loss in the sold put option.
NOTE: The trade brings profits only if Volatility drops in a few days, if it does not the trader should close the trade. If not closed the trade will be in loss with even a slight increase in volatility.
Max profit is attained when on expiry day the stock is exactly at the sold option strike and all options expire worthless. See the image below to understand:
This is very important: Iron Butterfly is a Volatility play and NOT a directional or non-directional trade like what most traders think. Its results depends a lot on what happens to volatility after the trade is made. Direction of the stock within a small range will not effect much if lot of time remains for expiry. However if stock moves a lot fast, and volatility does not decrease, the trade stands to lose.
Why Iron Butterfly depends a lot on volatility?
Because ATM options have the highest time value or theta – volatility therefore has a lot of affect on these options. For example if Nifty is at exactly at 8300, then both the ATM options will have zero intrinsic value which means whatever premium they have is nothing but time value and prevailing volatility.
Assuming that both ATM call option and PUT option have a premium of 150 at the start of the month, if Nifty does not move (which is impossible), both the options will become zero on the expiry. The buyer loses everything and the seller gets to keep all the premium. This is the reason why most trading happens on ATM options.
Interestingly professionals rarely trade ATM options, they almost always trade OTM options. So who trade at the money options? Traders who love to speculate and love to lose money. You will therefore see the tips providers, especially the ones who sell intraday Nifty option tips will ask you to buy ATM options. And if you have taken any tips from them, you must have lost money. 🙂
Sellers of ATM think they will keep all the premium or most of it as the stock will not move in future because its not moving now. Buyers think exactly the opposite, that the stock will go up or down so let me take a balanced risk. They do not buy ITM (in the money) as they have to pay a lot. And they fear buying OTM (out of the money) because they know chances of winning is less. So they buy ATM options. And since the buyers usually want to make money both sides a straddle is bought. Meaning they end up buying both ATM call and put. WORST TRADE EVER!
Sellers and buyers cannot time volatility, so they both lose. Buyers exit seeing the value not appreciating and take a loss. Sellers see the stock moving, their heart beat pounds, and they exit in a small profit or huge loss. 🙂
When I get calls from traders who are stuck at this position (buy both at the money call and put options) I actually get very angry. Their point of view is that they will make money wherever the stock goes because they are trading both the directions. Little do they realize that they have traded long volatility (it has to increase) and time is running against them like a time bomb. OR the stock has to trend in one direction too much in too little time. Both of the above is impossible to time.
And due to the same reason, traders sell ATM options because they want the maximum premium. Can you now sense what’s the reason for ATM option trading? Greed. Result is that most ATM Buyers and sellers lose money. 🙂
You can now guess what I will say next. Avoid trading Iron Butterfly. You cannot time volatility, and volatility does most damage to ATM options. A 10% drop or rise in volatility is common. So if you trade Iron Butterfly, sometimes you will make good money, some times you will lose. Overall the trade will not be profitable over a long period of time. Hope those who trade Butterfly now understand why you lose money when you sell ATM options. That’s because either the stock trends too much, or volatility increases.
For ATM option buyers its even more difficult, they have to fight time, the volatility has to increase and the stock has to trend and trend fast. If volatility drops, the premium too drops and overall they lose.
Iron Butterfly – the risk and reward:
Both the risk and reward is limited.
Now let me take real premiums and try to explain Iron Butterfly.
Date: 1 May 2015. Markets closed. Spot Nifty: 8181. We treat 8200 as ATM.
Sell 100 ATM (at the money) 8200 May 2015 Call option: 174
Sell 100 ATM (at the money) 8200 May 2015 Put option: 127
Buy 100 OTM (out of the money) 8300 May 2015 Call Option: 121
Buy 100 OTM (out of the money) 8100 May 2015 Put Option: 92
Total margin blocked: 8 lots sold * 14000 = 112,000, buying comes for free.
Note: An experience trader will wait for the volatility to reduce, and he will take out his profits. Where you are satisfied with your profits is something that no body can teach, but whenever there is a reasonable profit, they quit. It is the inexperienced traders who wait for the expiry because they want to take 100% of the profits which rarely happens.
However we need to calculate the profit and loss on the expiry day to explain this trade.
On May15 series expiry if Nifty is at 8200 the trade hits is Max profit:
Lets calculate:
All options expire worthless.
8200 May 2015 Call option: 174 * 100 = +17400
8200 May 2015 Put option: 127 * 100 = +12700
8300 May 2015 Call Option: 121 * 100 = -12100
8100 May 2015 Put Option: 92 * 100 = -9200
Total profit: 17400+12700-12100-9200 = 8800
ROI: (8800/112,000) * 100 = 7.85%
On expiry day if Nifty is at 8300:
8200 May 2015 Call option will be 100: (174-100) * 100 = +7400
8200 May 2015 Put option expires worthless: 127 * 100 = +12700
8300 May 2015 Call Option expires worthless: 121 * 100 = -12100
8100 May 2015 Put Option expires worthless: 92 * 100 = -9200
Total loss: 7400+12700-12100-9200 = -1200
On expiry day if Nifty is at 8100:
8200 May 2015 Call option will expires worthless: 174 * 100 = +17400
8200 May 2015 Put option will be 100: (127-100) * 100 = +2700
8300 May 2015 Call Option expires worthless: 121 * 100 = -12100
8100 May 2015 Put Option expires worthless: 92 * 100 = -9200
Total loss: 17400+2700-12100-9200 = -1200
So the trader profits only if Nifty closes close to 8200. Even if it is 100 points away the trader loses money.
What are the chances that Nifty will close exactly where it began at the start of the series? Very low. Therefore professional iron butterfly traders trade this as a volatility game, and exit as soon as there is a drop in volatility. A slight movement will not be able to damage the iron butterfly because the sold options are hedged. The sold options’ delta is higher than bought options’ delta and theta has Max effect on ATM options, if volatility drops this trade can give 2-3% return in days. That is enough for professional traders.
Do NOT wait till expiry, your profitable position may get into trouble. Though the loss is small, it may happen every time you trade. So waiting till expiry is not recommended.
If you are waiting till expiry in any trade than it is not the strategy that will make money for you, it is your luck that will. How many times were you lucky trading?
You can wait till expiry only in the strategies that are planned that way, for others you should exit when you are making a reasonable profit.
Conclusion:
- Iron Butterfly is done by selling at the money options of both calls and puts and buying just out of the money options to protect them.
- It is a volatility trade and not a directional trade or non-directional trade. Timing of volatility is important, else the trade may lose.
- Therefore it is traded by professional who have an idea of when the volatility is skewed and may drop.
- Waiting till expiry is not recommended.
- Exit whenever you are making a reasonable profit.
Have you traded the Iron Butterfly? If yes when do you exit the trade?
Click to Share this website with your friends on WhatsApp
COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT: Any act of copying, reproducing or distributing any content in the site or newsletters, whether wholly or in part, for any purpose without my permission is strictly prohibited and shall be deemed to be copyright infringement.
INCOME DISCLAIMER: Any references in this site of income made by the traders are given to me by them either through Email or WhatsApp as a Thank You message. However, every trade depends on the trader and his level of risk-taking capability, knowledge and experience. Moreover, stock market investments and trading are subject to market risks. Therefore there is no guarantee that everyone will achieve the same or similar results. My aim is to make you a better & disciplined trader with the stock trading and investing education and strategies you get from this website.
DISCLAIMER: I am NOT an Investment Adviser (IA). I do not give tips or advisory services by SMS, Email, WhatsApp or any other forms of social media. I strictly adhere to the laws of my country. I only offer education for free on finance, risk management & investments in stock markets through the articles on this website. You must consult an authorized Investment Adviser (IA) or do thorough research before investing in any stock or derivative using any strategy given on this website. I am not responsible for any investment decision you take after reading an article on this website. Click here to read the disclaimer in full.
My student gets the Winner's Certificate of Zerodha 60-day Challenge - Click here and Open Stock Buy and Sell Free Account with Them Today!!!
Testimonial by a Technical Analyst an Expert Trader - Results may vary for users
60% Profit Using Just Strategy 1 In A Financial Year – Results may vary for users
Testimonial by Housewife Trader - Results may vary for users
Comments on this entry are closed.
Thoroughly explained .i always thought iron butterfly is a non directional trade and often thought of trading it. But now understood it is not advisable to trade by a retail investor like me.Your articles are eye opener.
Great work dilip.
Anupam,
By the look and structure, yes it looks like a non-directional trade. So its not your fault. Someone selling ATM options is clearly selling Volatility assuming it drops and they buy it back. Works great in stocks. For example sell ATM call and put of a stock just before the results are out and hedge them – the iron butterfly is a perfect trade for that. Once the results are out and IF THERE IS NO MAJOR MOVEMENT – the trade will be in profit in hours. People reading this, please paper trade before you jump in to make money.
Thanks.