How To Trade Short Call Butterfly

If you have read my post on Long Call Butterfly, this trade will be easy for you to understand. Results for the Short Call Butterfly will be exactly opposite of the Long Call Butterfly.

Lets discuss the trade straight away.

When should you trade Short Call Butterfly?

You should trade this strategy when you think that Nifty will move away from the current strike and expire 100-200 points away on the either side – up or down does not matter.

Three trades are involved (note that these trades are exact opposite of the Long Call Butterfly):

1) Buy 2 lots ATM (at the money) Call Options
2) Sell 1 ITM (in the money) Call Option
3) Sell 1 OTM (out of the money) Call Option

Risk: Limited
Reward: Very Limited

Now lets take a real world example and what profit or loss the trader can make.

(Spot Nifty – 7905. Prices as of August 26, 2014 after markets closed. India VIX (Volatility) – 13.90 – Average. Taking September 2014 expiry as August expiry in 2 days. Option prices rounded off for clarity.)

1) 25-Sep-14 CE 7,900.00: 135.00

Buying 2 Lots = 135*50*2 = 13,500.00 (Debit from account)

2) 25-Sep-14 CE 7,800.00: 200.00

Selling 1 Lot = 200 * 50 * 1 = 10,000.00 (Credit into account)

3) 25-Sep-14 CE 8,000.00: 83.00

Selling 1 Lot = 83 * 50 * 1 = 4150.00 (Credit into account)

Total credit: 10,000 + 4150 – 13,500 = 650 (This is the maximum possible profit)

Total margin blocked: 62000 (approx)

ROI: (650/62000) * 100 = 1.04% in 30 days. In my view this is slightly better than a bank fixed deposit, and at par with many mutual funds. Any strategy that makes less than 2% in 30 days should not be traded. Trading is a business and returns should be attractive.

Return on investment is poor – in fact it is very poor. Such trades with low ROI and high risk are best avoided.

We will now see that risk-reward ratio in this trade is pathetic too – but success rate is good as there will be a movement in Nifty and near expiry if Nifty is away from the strike price of the bought calls – on either side, the trader can book his profits. But unfortunately one loss can take away months of profits. So lets try to find what happens if this trade is successful and what if not.

Lets take an example of when this trade is successful:

Nifty is exactly 200 points above bought call strike price of 7900: 7900 + 200 = 8100 on expiry day.

Calculations:

1) 7900 CE is 200: Profit: 200 – 135 = 65 * 50 * 2 = 6500
2) 7800 CE is 300: Loss: 200 – 300 = -100 * 50 * 1 = -5000
3) 8000 CE is 100: Loss: 100 – 83 = 17 * 50 = -850

Total profit: 6500-5000-850 = 650

Note that profit remains same if Nifty is above this anywhere.

Lets take an example of when this trade is successful on the down side:

Nifty is exactly 200 points below bought call strike price of 7900: 7900 – 200 = 7700 on expiry day.

1) 7900 CE is worthless: Loss: -13500
2) 7800 CE is also worthless: Profit: 10000
3) 8000 CE is also worthless: Profit: 4150

Total Profit: 10000 + 4150 – 13500 = 650

Note that if Nifty is anywhere below this on expiry day, the results will be same. The trader will make a small profit.

Now lets analyze the situations where the trader can make a loss.

Nifty is exactly on 7900 on expiry day – the strike price of the bought calls.

1) 7900 CE is worthless: Loss: -13500
2) 7800 CE is 100: Profit: 200 – 100 = 100 * 50 = 5000
3) 8000 CE is also worthless: Profit:: 4150

Total loss: 5000+4150-13500 = -4350

Nifty at 8000:

1) 7900 CE is 100: Loss: 135 – 100 = 35 * 50 * 2 = -3500
2) 7800 CE is 200: No Profit No Loss as it was 200 = 0
3) 8000 CE is worthless: Profit: 83 * 50 = 4150

Total Profit: 4150-3500 = 650

We have already calculated 8100 and above will be same.

Nifty at 7800:

1) 7900 CE is worthless: Loss: -13500
2) 7800 CE is also worthless: Profit: 10000
3) 8000 CE is also worthless: Profit: 4150

Total Profit: 10000 + 4150 – 13500 = 650

We have already calculated 7700 and below, the results will be same.

So what do you make out from this trade? This is one of the worst trades to try out. Agreed mostly you will make a profit, but one loss will take away nearly 7 months of profits (4350/650 = 6.7). I have not even added the brokerage to this profit of 650. 4+4 = 8 trades are involved to open and to close. Calculate yourself what kind of profits remains even if this trade is successful most of the times.

My advice: Stay away from such trades when risk-reward is pathetic and on top of that you may be hoping that Nifty is nowhere near the bought strike price during the expiry week.

How To Adjust A Short Call Butterfly:

This is also a set-and-forget trade. If you see profits (even a small one) on any day before expiry – it is advised that you close the trade because at any cost you should not take the maximum loss.

If you keep rolling over whenever Nifty comes near the bought calls strike – you will take a loss every time you do. Therefore rollover is not recommended.

You cannot wait till expiry as this trade can make a big loss on that day. Also you will not get good profits when Nifty is away from the bought calls strike price and expiry is not near. When you close it few days before expiry, you may make some money but that will be less than the max profit. On top of that, eight transaction will involve a lot of money in brokerage.

Therefore this is a trade better avoided.

Have you ever traded a Short Call Butterfly? I am eager to know the results.

COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT: Any act of copying, reproducing or distributing any content in the site or newsletters, whether wholly or in part, for any purpose without my permission is strictly prohibited and shall be deemed to be copyright infringement.

INCOME DISCLAIMER: Any references in this site of income made by the traders are given to me by them either through Email or WhatsApp as a Thank You message. However, every trade depends on the trader and his level of risk-taking capability, knowledge and experience. Moreover, stock market investments and trading are subject to market risks. Therefore there is no guarantee that everyone will achieve the same or similar results. My aim is to make you a better & disciplined trader with the stock trading and investing education and strategies you get from this website.

DISCLAIMER: I am NOT an Investment Adviser (IA). I do not give tips or advisory services by SMS, Email, WhatsApp or any other forms of social media. I strictly adhere to the laws of my country. I only offer education for free on finance, risk management & investments in stock markets through the articles on this website. You must consult an authorized Investment Adviser (IA) or do thorough research before investing in any stock or derivative using any strategy given on this website. I am not responsible for any investment decision you take after reading an article on this website. Click here to read the disclaimer in full.

Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | Refund Policy | About Me | Conservative Option Course | 200+ Testimonials - What Traders Say About This Course | Contact Me

My student gets the Winner's Certificate of Zerodha 60-day Challenge - Click here and Open Stock Buy and Sell Free Account with Them Today!!!